About Bar Heretic

Cocktail BarHappy hour

Bar Heretic is a Fort Greene natural-wine bar built around house-baked breads, small savory plates, and an easygoing, talkative atmosphere. Expect low-intervention bottles sourced from thoughtful producers alongside snacks and shareable dishes designed to pair with every glass. It’s the kind of neighborhood spot where bartenders double as bread bakers and strangers end up swapping recommendations.

What to Order

Daily Sourdough with Cultured Butter

A rustic, blistered loaf served warm with silky cultured butter — the foundational comfort for every bottle.

Smoked Fish Toasts

House-smoked fish, lemony labneh and dill over crisped bread for a briny, bright bite.

Seasonal Vegetable Mezze

A rotating selection of pickles, charred veg and hummus-style spreads meant for passing and pairing.

See what's cooking

Gallery 0

More new restaurants in Brooklyn

Lonnies Restaurant and Bar
Boerum Hill
Cocktail BarHappy hour
Lonnies Restaurant and Bar offers a laid-back atmosphere with a diverse menu featuring American comfort food and an extensive selection of craft cocktails, making it a popular spot for both locals and visitors.
View
Sunset Park
AmericanLunch spot
Sunset Park Plaza is a warm, community-focused spot in the heart of Sunset Park featuring charming outdoor seating with park views and an eclectic, globally inspired menu made with locally sourced ingredients. With signature dishes like the Sunset Bowl and Brooklyn BBQ Ribs, diverse options for various diets, and weekly live music, it's an inviting place for friends and family to gather.
View
Tavern Next Door
Red Hook
American
Tavern Next Door is a cozy Red Hook neighborhood eatery where seasonal, locally sourced ingredients and inventive cocktails meet comfort classics like house-made ricotta toast, braised short ribs, and a craft burger. With outdoor seating and weekly live music, it’s a welcoming spot for relaxed brunches, lively dinners, and casual nights out.
View
Kinda Nice
Southside
Cocktail BarLate night
Kinda Nice in Southside, Brooklyn pairs locally sourced ingredients with an adventurous fusion menu—highlighted by artfully plated Global Tacos and the Kinda Nice Bowl—and serves creative craft cocktails in a cozy, artful setting perfect for casual yet sophisticated dining.
View
Bar Heretic cover

Bar Heretic

Opened January 2026
Fort Greene, Brooklyn
Unclaimed listing